1.13. Object-Oriented Programming in C++: Defining Classes

We stated earlier that C++ is an object-oriented programming language. So far, we have used a number of built-in classes to show examples of data and control structures. One of the most powerful features in an object-oriented programming language is the ability to allow a programmer (problem solver) to create new classes that model data that is needed to solve the problem.

Remember that we use abstract data types to provide the logical description of what a data object looks like (its state) and what it can do (its methods). By building a class that implements an abstract data type, a programmer can take advantage of the abstraction process and at the same time provide the details necessary to actually use the abstraction in a program. Whenever we want to implement an abstract data type, we will do so with a new class.

1.13.1. A Fraction Class

A very common example to show the details of implementing a user-defined class is to construct a class to implement the abstract data type Fraction. We have already seen that C++ provides a number of numeric classes for our use. There are times, however, that it would be most appropriate to be able to create data objects that “look like” fractions.

A fraction such as \(\frac {3}{5}\) consists of two parts. The top value, known as the numerator, can be any integer. The bottom value, called the denominator, can be any integer greater than 0 (negative fractions have a negative numerator). Although it is possible to create a floating point approximation for any fraction, in this case we would like to represent the fraction as an exact value.

The operations for the Fraction type will allow a Fraction data object to behave like any other numeric value. We need to be able to add, subtract, multiply, and divide fractions. We also want to be able to show fractions using the standard “slash” form, for example 3/5. In addition, all fraction methods should return results in their lowest terms so that no matter what computation is performed, we always end up with the most common form.

In C++, we define a new class by providing a name and a set of method definitions that are syntactically similar to function definitions. For this example,

class Fraction {
    // The methods and class variables go here
};

provides the framework for us to define the methods. The first method that all classes should provide is the constructor. The constructor defines the way in which data objects are created. To create a Fraction object, we will need to provide two pieces of data, the numerator and the denominator. In C++, the constructor method is always called the same name as the class it creates and is shown in Listing 2.

Listing 2

class Fraction {
    private:
    int num;
    int den;

    public:
    Fraction(int top, int bottom) {
        num = top;
        den = bottom;
    }
};

As described earlier, fractions require two pieces of state data, the numerator and the denominator. The notation int num outside the constructor defines the fraction object to have an internal data object called num as part of its state. Likewise, int den creates the denominator. The values of the two formal parameters are initially assigned to the state, allowing the new fraction object to know its starting value. Any variables under the private keyword will only be able to be accessed by the objects functions, not the user. public methods and variables can be accessed and used by the user. Because we want our user to be able to call our constructor directly, we put it under public.

We can also overload a constructor with different numbers and types of arguments to give us more optional ways to create an instance of the class in question. For example, we could add an optional secondary constructor to handle whole numbers:

Fraction(int top, int bottom) {
    num = top;
    den = bottom;
}

Fraction (int top) {
    num = top;
    den = 1;
}

To create an instance of the Fraction class, we must invoke the constructor. This happens by using the name of the class and passing actual values for the necessary state after the variable name. For example,

Fraction myfraction(3,5);

creates an object called myfraction representing the fraction \(\frac {3}{5}\) (three-fifths). Figure 5 shows this object as it is now implemented.

../_images/fraction1.png

Figure 5: An Instance of the Fraction Class

The next thing we need to do is implement the behavior that the abstract data type requires. To begin, consider what happens when we try to print a Fraction object.

int main() {
    Fraction myfraction(3,5);

    // Throws an error
    cout<<myfraction<<endl;

    return 0;
}

The fraction object, myfraction, does not know how to respond to this request to print. The cout function requires that the object knows how to interact with the << operator so that the string can be sent to the output stream. Without this, our class will throw an error. This is not what we want.

There are two ways we can solve this problem. One is to define a method called show that will allow the Fraction object to print itself as a string. We can implement this method as shown in Listing 3. If we create a Fraction object as before, we can ask it to show itself, in other words, print itself in the proper format. Unfortunately, this does not work in general. In order to make printing work properly, we need to tell the Fraction class how to interact with the << operator. This is what the cout function needs in order to do its job.

In C++, there are many operators that are provided but may not work properly. One of these, <<, is the operator to send data down the output stream. What we need to do is provide a “better” implementation for this method. We will say that this implementation is a friend of the previous one, or that it redefines the operator’s behavior.

To do this, we declare a friend method with the name << inside the class and give it a new implementation outside as shown in Listing 4. This definition needs to return a stream in this case. The resulting output will be returned any time a Fraction object is asked to interact with the << operator.

Listing 4

We can override many other methods for our new Fraction class. Some of the most important of these are the basic arithmetic operations. We would like to be able to create two Fraction objects and then add them together using the standard “+” notation. At this point, if we try to add two fractions, we get the following:

Fraction f1(1,4);
Fraction f2(1,2);
Fraction f3=f1+f2;

invalid operands to binary expression ('Fraction' and 'Fraction')

If you look closely at the error, you see that the problem is that the “+” operator does not understand the Fraction operands.

We can fix this by providing the Fraction class with a method that overrides the addition method. In C++, this method is called + and it requires two parameters. The first, self, is always needed, and the second represents the other operand in the expression. For example,

f1.__add__(f2)

would ask the Fraction object f1 to add the Fraction object f2 to itself. This can be written in the standard notation, f1+f2.

Two fractions must have the same denominator to be added. The easiest way to make sure they have the same denominator is to simply use the product of the two denominators as a common denominator so that \(\frac {a}{b} + \frac {c}{d} = \frac {ad}{bd} + \frac {cb}{bd} = \frac{ad+cb}{bd}\) The implementation is shown in Listing 5. The addition function returns a new Fraction object with the numerator and denominator of the sum. We can use this method by writing a standard arithmetic expression involving fractions, assigning the result of the addition, and then printing our result.

Listing 5

Fraction operator +(Fraction otherFrac) {
    int newnum = num*otherFrac.den + den*otherFrac.num;
    int newden = den*otherFrac.den;

    return Fraction(newnum,newden);
}

The addition method works as we desire, but one thing could be better. Note that \(6/8\) is the correct result (\(\frac {1}{4} + \frac {1}{2}\)) but that it is not in the “lowest terms” representation. The best representation would be \(3/4\). In order to be sure that our results are always in the lowest terms, we need a helper function that knows how to reduce fractions. This function will need to look for the greatest common divisor, or GCD. We can then divide the numerator and the denominator by the GCD and the result will be reduced to lowest terms.

The best-known algorithm for finding a greatest common divisor is Euclid’s Algorithm, which will be discussed in detail in Chapter 8. Euclid’s Algorithm states that the greatest common divisor of two integers \(m\) and \(n\) is \(n\) if \(n\) divides \(m\) evenly. However, if \(n\) does not divide \(m\) evenly, then the answer is the greatest common divisor of \(n\) and the remainder of \(m\) divided by \(n\). We will simply provide an iterative implementation here (see ActiveCode 1). Note that this implementation of the GCD algorithm only works when the denominator is positive. This is acceptable for our fraction class because we have said that a negative fraction will be represented by a negative numerator.

Now we can use this function to help reduce any fraction. To put a fraction in lowest terms, we will divide the numerator and the denominator by their greatest common divisor. So, for the fraction \(6/8\), the greatest common divisor is 2. Dividing the top and the bottom by 2 creates a new fraction, \(3/4\) (see Listing 6).

Listing 6

../_images/fraction2.png

Figure 6: An Instance of the Fraction Class with Two Methods

Our Fraction object now has two very useful methods and looks like Figure 6. An additional group of methods that we need to include in our example Fraction class will allow two fractions to compare themselves to one another. Assume we have two Fraction objects, f1 and f2. f1==f2 will only be true if they are references to the same object. Two different objects with the same numerators and denominators would not be equal under this implementation. This is called shallow equality (see Figure 7).

../_images/fraction3.png

Figure 7: Shallow Equality Versus Deep Equality

We can create deep equality (see Figure 7)–equality by the same value, not the same reference–by overriding the == method. The == operator is another standard method available in any class. The == operator compares two objects and returns true if their values are the same, false otherwise.

In the Fraction class, we can implement the == method by again putting the two fractions in common terms and then comparing the numerators (see Listing 7). It is important to note that there are other relational operators that can be overridden. For example, the <= operator provides the less than or equal functionality.

Listing 7

bool operator ==(Fraction &otherFrac) {
    int firstnum = num*otherFrac.den;
    int secondnum = otherFrac.num*den;

    return firstnum==secondnum;
}

The complete Fraction class, up to this point, is shown in ActiveCode 6. We leave the remaining arithmetic and relational methods as exercises.

Self Check

To make sure you understand how operators are implemented in C++ classes, and how to properly write methods, write some methods to implement *, /, and - . Also implement comparison operators > and <

1.13.2. Inheritance: Logic Gates and Circuits

Our final section will introduce another important aspect of object-oriented programming. Inheritance is the ability for one class to be related to another class n much the same way that people can be related to one another. Children inherit characteristics from their parents. Similarly, C++ child classes can inherit characteristic data and behavior from a parent class. These classes are often referred to as subclasses and base classes.

Figure 8 shows the built-in C++ collections and their relationships to one another. We call a relationship structure such as this an inheritance hierarchy. For example, the list is a child of the sequential collection. In this case, we call the list the child and the sequence the parent (or subclass list and superclass sequence). This is often referred to as an IS-A Relationship (the list IS-A sequential collection). This implies that lists inherit important characteristics from sequences, namely the ordering of the underlying data and operations such as concatenation, repetition, and indexing.

../_images/inheritance1.png

Figure 8: An Inheritance Hierarchy for C++ Collections

Vectors, arrays, and strings are all types of sequential collections. They all inherit common data organization and operations. However, each of them is distinct based on whether the data is homogeneous and whether the collection is immutable. The children all gain from their parents but distinguish themselves by adding additional characteristics.

By organizing classes in this hierarchical fashion, object-oriented programming languages allow previously written code to be extended to meet the needs of a new situation. In addition, by organizing data in this hierarchical manner, we can better understand the relationships that exist. We can be more efficient in building our abstract representations.

To explore this idea further, we will construct a simulation, an application to simulate digital circuits. The basic building block for this simulation will be the logic gate. These electronic switches represent boolean algebra relationships between their input and their output. In general, gates have a single output line. The value of the output is dependent on the values given on the input lines.

AND gates have two input lines, each of which can be either 0 or 1 (representing false or true, repectively). If both of the input lines have the value 1, the resulting output is 1. However, if either or both of the input lines is 0, the result is 0. OR gates also have two input lines and produce a 1 if one or both of the input values is a 1. In the case where both input lines are 0, the result is 0.

NOT gates differ from the other two gates in that they only have a single input line. The output value is simply the opposite of the input value. If 0 appears on the input, 1 is produced on the output. Similarly, 1 produces 0. Figure 9 shows how each of these gates is typically represented. Each gate also has a truth table of values showing the input-to-output mapping that is performed by the gate.

../_images/truthtable.png

Figure 9: Three Types of Logic Gates

By combining these gates in various patterns and then applying a set of input values, we can build circuits that have logical functions. Figure 10 shows a circuit consisting of two AND gates, one OR gate, and a single NOT gate. The output lines from the two AND gates feed directly into the OR gate, and the resulting output from the OR gate is given to the NOT gate. If we apply a set of input values to the four input lines (two for each AND gate), the values are processed and a result appears at the output of the NOT gate. Figure 10 also shows an example with values.

../_images/circuit1.png

Figure 10: Circuit

In order to implement a circuit, we will first build a representation for logic gates. Logic gates are easily organized into a class inheritance hierarchy as shown in Figure 11. At the top of the hierarchy, the LogicGate class represents the most general characteristics of logic gates: namely, a label for the gate and an output line. The next level of subclasses breaks the logic gates into two families, those that have one input line and those that have two. Below that, the specific logic functions of each appear.

../_images/gates.png

Figure 11: An Inheritance Hierarchy for Logic Gates

We can now start to implement the classes by starting with the most general, LogicGate. As noted earlier, each gate has a label for identification and a single output line. In addition, we need methods to allow a user of a gate to ask the gate for its label.

The other behavior that every logic gate needs is the ability to know its output value. This will require that the gate perform the appropriate logic based on the current input. In order to produce output, the gate needs to know specifically what that logic is. This means calling a method to perform the logic computation. The complete class is shown in Listing 8.

Listing 8

class LogicGate {
    private:
            string label;
            bool output;

    public:
            LogicGate(string n) {
                    label = n;
            }

            string getLabel() {
                    return label;
            }

            bool getOutput() {
                    output = performGateLogic();
                    return output;
        }
};

At this point, we will not implement the performGateLogic function. The reason for this is that we do not know how each gate will perform its own logic operation. Those details will be included by each individual gate that is added to the hierarchy. This is a very powerful idea in object-oriented programming. We are writing a method that will use code that does not exist yet. The parameter virtual is a reference to the actual gate object invoking the method. Any new logic gate that gets added to the hierarchy will simply need to implement the performGateLogic function and it will be used at the appropriate time. Once done, the gate can provide its output value. This ability to extend a hierarchy that currently exists and provide the specific functions that the hierarchy needs to use the new class is extremely important for reusing existing code.

We categorized the logic gates based on the number of input lines. The AND gate has two input lines. The OR gate also has two input lines. NOT gates have one input line. The BinaryGate class will be a subclass of LogicGate and will add two input lines. The UnaryGate class will also subclass LogicGate but will have only a single input line. In computer circuit design, these lines are sometimes called “pins” so we will use that terminology in our implementation.

Listing 9

class BinaryGate : public LogicGate {
    private:
        bool pinA;
        bool pinATaken;
        bool pinB;
        bool pinBTaken;

    public:
        BinaryGate(string n) : LogicGate(n) {
            pinATaken = false;
            pinBTaken = false;
        }

        bool getPinA() {
            if (pinATaken==false) {
                cout << "Enter Pin input for gate " << getLabel() << " -->";
                cin >> pinA;
                pinATaken = true;
            }
            return pinA;
        }

        bool getPinB() {
            if (pinBTaken==false ) {
                cout << "Enter Pin input for gate " << getLabel() << " -->";
                cin >> pinB;
                pinBTaken = true;
            }
            return pinB;
        }
};

Listing 10

class UnaryGate : public LogicGate {
    private:
        bool pin;
        bool pinTaken;

    public:
        UnaryGate(string n) : LogicGate(n) {
            pinTaken = false;
        }

        bool getPin() {
            if (pinTaken==false) {
                cout << "Enter Pin input for gate " << getLabel() << " -->";
                cin >> pin;
                pinTaken = true;
            }
            return pin;
        }
};

Listing 9 and Listing 10 implement these two classes. The constructors in both of these classes start with an explicit call to the constructor of the parent class using the parent’s name method. When creating an instance of the BinaryGate class, we first want to initialize any data items that are inherited from LogicGate. In this case, that means the label for the gate. The constructor then goes on to add the two input lines (pinA and pinB). This is a very common pattern that you should always use when building class hierarchies. Child class constructors need to call parent class constructors and then move on to their own distinguishing data.

A simple example of using a virtual function in C++ is shown below.

The only behavior that the BinaryGate class adds is the ability to get the values from the two input lines. Since these values come from some external place, we will simply ask the user via an input statement to provide them. The same implementation occurs for the UnaryGate class except that there is only one input line.

Now that we have a general class for gates depending on the number of input lines, we can build specific gates that have unique behavior. For example, the AndGate class will be a subclass of BinaryGate since AND gates have two input lines. As before, the first line of the constructor calls upon the parent class constructor (BinaryGate), which in turn calls its parent class constructor (LogicGate). Note that the AndGate class does not provide any new data since it inherits two input lines, one output line, and a label.

Listing 11

class AndGate : public BinaryGate {
    public:
        AndGate(string n) : BinaryGate(n) {};

        virtual bool performGateLogic() {
            bool a = getPinA();
            bool b = getPinB();
            if (a == 1 && b == 1) {
                return true;
            }
            else {
                return false;
            }
        }
};

The only thing AndGate needs to add is the specific behavior that performs the boolean operation that was described earlier. This is the place where we can provide the performGateLogic method. For an AND gate, this method first must get the two input values and then only return 1 if both input values are 1. The complete class is shown in Listing 11.

We can show the AndGate class in action by creating an instance and asking it to compute its output. The following session shows an AndGate object, g1, that has an internal label "G1". When we invoke the getOutput method, the object must first call its performGateLogic method which in turn queries the two input lines. Once the values are provided, the correct output is shown.

>>> AndGate g1("G1")
>>> g1.getOutput()
Enter Pin A input for gate G1-->1
Enter Pin B input for gate G1-->0
0

The same development can be done for OR gates and NOT gates. The OrGate class will also be a subclass of BinaryGate and the NotGate class will extend the UnaryGate class. Both of these classes will need to provide their own performGateLogic functions, as this is their specific behavior.

We can use a single gate by first constructing an instance of one of the gate classes and then asking the gate for its output (which will in turn need inputs to be provided). For example:

>>> OrGate g2("G2")
>>> g2.getOutput()
Enter Pin A input for gate G2-->1
Enter Pin B input for gate G2-->1
1
>>> g2.getOutput()
Enter Pin A input for gate G2-->0
Enter Pin B input for gate G2-->0
0
>>> NotGate g3("G3")
>>> g3.getOutput()
Enter Pin input for gate G3-->0
1

Now that we have the basic gates working, we can turn our attention to building circuits. In order to create a circuit, we need to connect gates together, the output of one flowing into the input of another. To do this, we will implement a new class called Connector.

The Connector class will not reside in the gate hierarchy. It will, however, use the gate hierarchy in that each connector will have two gates, one on either end (see Figure 12). This relationship is very important in object-oriented programming. It is called the HAS-A Relationship. Recall earlier that we used the phrase “IS-A Relationship” to say that a child class is related to a parent class, for example UnaryGate IS-A LogicGate.

../_images/connector.png

Figure 12: A Connector Connects the Output of One Gate to the Input of Another

Now, with the Connector class, we say that a Connector HAS-A LogicGate meaning that connectors will have instances of the LogicGate class within them but are not part of the hierarchy. When designing classes, it is very important to distinguish between those that have the IS-A relationship (which requires inheritance) and those that have HAS-A relationships (with no inheritance).

Listing 12 shows the Connector class. The two gate instances within each connector object will be referred to as the fromgate and the togate, recognizing that data values will “flow” from the output of one gate into an input line of the next. The call to setNextPin is very important for making connections (see Listing 13). We need to add this method to our gate classes so that each togate can choose the proper input line for the connection.

Listing 12

class Connector {
    private:
            LogicGate *fromgate;
            LogicGate *togate;

    public:
            Connector(LogicGate *fgate, LogicGate *tgate) {
                    fromgate = fgate;
                    togate = tgate;
                    tgate->setNextPin(fromgate->getOutput());
            }

            LogicGate *getFrom() {
                    return fromgate;
            }

            LogicGate *getTo() {
                    return togate;
            }
};

In the BinaryGate class, for gates with two possible input lines, the connector must be connected to only one line. If both of them are available, we will choose pinA by default. If pinA is already connected, then we will choose pinB. It is not possible to connect to a gate with no available input lines.

Listing 13

virtual void setNextPin(bool source) {
    if (pinATaken == false) {
        pinA = source;
        pinATaken=true;
        return;
    }
    else if (pinBTaken == false) {
        pinB = source;
        pinBTaken=true;
        return;
    }
    else {
        cout << "ERROR: ALL PINS TAKEN" << endl;
    }
}

Now it is possible to get input from two places: externally, as before, and from the output of a gate that is connected to that input line. This requires a change to the getPinA and getPinB methods (see Listing 14). If the input line is not connected to anything (None), then ask the user externally as before. However, if there is a connection, the connection is accessed and fromgate’s output value is retrieved. This in turn causes that gate to process its logic. This continues until all input is available and the final output value becomes the required input for the gate in question. In a sense, the circuit works backwards to find the input necessary to finally produce output.

Listing 14

bool getPinA() {
    if (pinATaken==false) {
        cout << "Enter Pin input for gate " << getLabel() << " -->";
        cin >> pinA;
        pinATaken = true;
    }
    return pinA;
}

The following fragment constructs the circuit shown earlier in the section:

AndGate g1("AND1");
    AndGate g2("AND2");
    OrGate g3("OR3");
    NotGate g4("NOT4");
    Connector c1(&g1, &g2);
    Connector c2(&g2, &g3);
    Connector c3(&g3, &g4);

The outputs from the two AND gates (g1 and g2) are connected to the OR gate (g3) and that output is connected to the NOT gate (g4). The output from the NOT gate is the output of the entire circuit. For example:

>>> g4.getOutput()
Pin A input for gate G1-->0
Pin B input for gate G1-->1
Pin A input for gate G2-->1
Pin B input for gate G2-->1
0

Try it yourself using ActiveCode 4.

Self Check Challenge

One of the fundamental building blocks of a computer is something called a flip flop. It’s not something that computer science professors wear on their feet, but rather a kind of circuit that is stable and stores the last piece of data that was put on it. A simple flip-flop can be made from two NOR gates that are tied together as in the following diagram.

../_images/flipflop.png

Note if the initial inputs to Reset and Set are both 0 then the output of the flip-flop is 0. But if the Set input is toggled to 1 then the output becomes 1. The great thing is that when the set input goes to 0 the output stays 1, until the reset input is toggled to 1 which resets the output of the circuit back to zero.

Next Section - 1.14. Summary